John B. Oakes Papers, 1932-1969

Container Title
Micro 728
Series: Part III, 1979 Additions, 1950-1960
Reel   1
Governors' Conferences, 1954, 1956, 1958
Scope and Content Note

Materials in the governors' conferences file cover such subjects as Senator Joseph McCarthy, Dwight D. Eisenhower, the farm problem, segregation and integration, and state economics.

Of particular interest are an “opinion poll” on Senator McCarthy; and an interview with Herman Talmadge on the upcoming elections and integration.

A long memorandum on the whole 1954 conference includes statements by the following: William Stratton of Illinois; Knight of California Walter Kohler of Wisconsin; Christian Herter of Massachusetts; Edwin L. Mecham of New Mexico; G. Merman Williams of Michigan; C.J. Rogers of Wyoming; Meyner of New Jersey; Dan Thornton of Colorado; Robert F. Kennon of Louisiana; J. Cable Boggs of Delaware; John S. Fine of Pennsylvania; Lawrence F. Wetherby of Kentucky; John David Lodge of Connecticut; Dennis J. Roberts of Rhode Island; Secretary McKay (former governor of Oregon); Peterson (Civil Defense administrator and former governor of Nebraska).

A short memorandum on the 1956 conference sets forth the governors' opinion that Stevenson was definitely in as the Democratic Presidential nominee, and Eisenhower as the Republican.

A long memorandum on the 1958 conference includes statements by the following: Williams of Michigan; Ribicoff of Connecticut; Harriman of New York; Coleman of Mississippi; Collins of Florida; Faubus of Arkansas; Rossellini of Washington; Leader of Pennsylvania; Freeman of Minnesota; Muskie of Maine; Holmes of Oregon; Docking of Kansas; McNichols of Colorado; Stratton of Illinois; Thompson of Wisconsin; Durnell of New Hampshire; O'Neill of Ohio; Handley of Indiana; Smylie of Idaho; Boggs of Delaware; Johnson of Vermont; Anderson of Nebraska; Davis of North Dakota.

Reel   1
McCarthy-Communism Controversy
Scope and Content Note

Materials in this file include a letter from Westbrook Pegler relating to Oakes' review of a book about McCarthy; a letter concerning new evidence in the Hiss case; papers concerning Fifth Amendment cases on the Times; a debate by correspondence on a McCarthyism program on which Oakes appeared; a long letter from John Howe on Cardinal Spellman coming out for McCarthy and the “Who has Joe hurt?” theory.

There is also a long memorandum of a trip to Washington, D.C., June 28-30, 1954, in which appear statements by Lyndon E. Johnson; Charles E. Potter of Michigan; Homer Ferguson of Michigan; J.W. Fulbright of Arkansas; John F. Kennedy; Prescott Bush of Connecticut; A.S. (Mike) Monroney of Oklahoma; Stuart Symington of Missouri; William Knowland of California; Stuyvesant Wainwright of New York; and Max Rabb (Secretary of the Cabinet and member of the White House staff). These statements reflect the general feeling, at that time, that the McCarthy censure would not come to a vote.

A report, November 17, 1954, on the censure debate is in the form of a letter.

The final portion of the McCarthy file is made up of materials relating to the “Dear Grace, Dear Iphigene” letters. There is a long memorandum from Ralph de Toledano to Mrs. Roosevelt defending McCarthy against Oakes; a memorandum from Oakes to Mrs. Sulzberger; copies of some of the letters exchanged by Mrs. Roosevelt and Mrs. Sulzberger; and a clipping of Westbrook Pegler's column relating to these letters.

Reel   1
Reports, Interviews With Government Officials, Washington
Note: In reverse chronological order except that 1960 is at the end of the list
Reel   1
1958 February 5-8
Scope and Content Note: Principal issue discussed is the recession. The report includes statements by the following:
  • Sherman Adams - Ike is a “fragile mechanism”
  • Meade Alcorn - The GOP is looking up after a bad year
  • William F. Knowland
  • Paul Butler
  • Lyndon Johnson - Alleges he is not a Presidential candidate and that his interest in missiles is nonpolitical
  • Styles Bridges
  • Mike Monroney - Kennedy is trying too hard too soon
  • Lister Hill
  • Paul Douglas - Discusses unemployment
  • Henry Jackson
  • Joseph S. Clark
  • Stuart Symington - Comments on the inadequate defense program
  • Hubert Humphrey
  • Secretary Folsom - Comments on the educational bill
  • George Allen (USIA)
  • John F. Kennedy- Defends his authorship of Profiles in Courage
Reel   1
1957 November 12-15; December 3-4
Scope and Content Note

Principal subject is foreign affairs. The report includes statements by the following:

  • Christian Herter - The Arabs are accepting the reality of Israel
  • C. Douglas Dillon - Russian foreign aid is starting to amount to something
  • Clarence Randall - Comments on reciprocal trade
  • Paule Nitze - Dulles sees himself as the “lone fighter against the forces of evil”
  • Stuart Rockwell - Favorable comments on the Arabs; says that Jordan will be cut up
  • William S.B. Lacy
  • Francis Wilcox
  • Charles Owsley
  • J. William Fulbright - Eisenhower should resign
  • Carl Durham
  • Hertzog (Israeli Ambassador to the United States) - The whole Middle East is in danger from Russia
  • Dean Acheson

Principal subject is domestic affairs. The report contains statements by the following:

  • Paul Butler
  • Lyndon Johnson and Speaker Rayburn - Comment on Stevenson and the bipartisanship question
  • James Douglas and Malcolm Maclntyre - Comment on the missile gap
  • Arthur Larson - Eisenhower is weak
  • Attorney General William Rogers - Comments on the new internal security program
  • Gordon Gray
  • William Proxmire
  • Clifford Case
Reel   1
1957 May 7-10
Scope and Content Note: The report includes statements by the following:
  • Richard Nixon - Comments on the budget and taxes and their relation to the voters; USIA; and the school bill mess
  • Meade Alcorn
  • Arthur Larsen (USIA)
  • Styles Bridges
  • Thruston Morton
  • Margaret Chase Smith
  • Charles E. Potter
  • Christian Herter - Comments on the Mideast mess
  • Rountree (Undersecretary for the Mideast)
  • Max Rabb
  • Lyndon Johnson - Believes he is attacked unfairly; miffed that Rayburn does not get such treatment
  • Monroney
  • John F. Kennedy
  • Paul Douglas - The Liberal Democrats control conventions, but the South controls Congress
  • Joseph S. Clark
  • Patrick V. McNamara
  • Frank Church
  • Henry S. Reuss
Reel   1
1957 January 30-February 1
Scope and Content Note: Principal subjects are the Mideast crisis and the “direction” of the Democrats. The report contains statements by the following:
  • Lyndon Johnson - Defensive about leadership and sensitive to criticism; particularly contemptuous of Humphrey; does not want and is not competent to be President; jealous of Rayburn
  • Fulbright - Expresses no confidence in Dulles
  • Mansfield
  • Lausche - Eisenhower's liberalism is a Republican flash in the pan
  • Russell - Should cut foreign aid
  • Clark
  • Carroll
  • Paul Butler
  • George McGhee
  • Knowland
  • Cooper - Eisenhower's Mideast program is too military and too exclusively anti-Communist
  • Morton
  • Case
Reel   1
1956 April 28
Scope and Content Note: The report includes statements by the following:
  • Cotton
  • Allott
  • Jiggs Donohue
  • Solicitor General Sobeloff
Reel   1
1956 January 30-February?; February 29-March 1
Scope and Content Note: The report contains statements by the following:
  • Goldwater - For Nixon
  • Kefauver - Comments on why Stevenson cannot win
  • Gore - Eisenhower will run
  • Dirksen
  • Clinton P. Anderson
  • Neuberger
  • Monroney
  • Kuchel
  • Case - Eisenhower should ditch Nixon; Israel could beat the Arabs, but the Communists would move in
  • Symington
  • Jackson
  • Hennings
  • Max Rabb
  • Udall
  • Felix Frankfurter
  • John F. Kennedy - Gloomy about Democratic chances
Reel   1
1955 December 6
Scope and Content Note: Interview with Nixon. Nixon comments on the “electability” of candidates; says that farm prices are not important after the farmers have voted.
Reel   1
1955 December 6
Scope and Content Note: The report contains statements by the following:
  • Douglas
  • Mansfield
  • Ives
  • Knowland
Reel   1
1955 January 18-21
Scope and Content Note: Principal subject is the Democrats' search for a program. The report includes statements by the following:
  • Mansfield
  • Neuberger
  • Morse
  • Knowland
  • Doughs
  • Halleck - Eisenhower has to run
  • Max Rabb - Eisenhower is security conscious
  • Cain - We need more freedom and less “security”
1954 June 28-30
Scope and Content Note: Report reflects optimism of the Republicans. Statements by the following are included:
  • Johnson - McCarthy is dangerous, but he (J.) refuses to take part in anti-McCarthy moves; it's an internal Republican matter
Reel   1
1954 January 11-15
Scope and Content Note: Subjects covered include McCarthy, the Bricker Amendment, and the farm program. The report contains statements by the following:
  • Nixon
  • McLeod - Comments on immigration
  • Halleck
  • Wainwright
  • Rayburn
  • Anderson
  • Sparkman
  • Monroney - McCarthy will have to turn on Eisenhower
  • Johnson
  • Kennedy
  • Douglas
  • Knowland
  • Millikin
  • Mrs. Smith
  • Symington
  • Max Rabb
  • Hagerty
  • Javits
  • Raskin
  • Streibert
Reel   1
1953 February 16-20
Scope and Content Note: The report includes statements by the following:
  • Nixon
  • Taft
  • Millikin
  • Aiken
  • Ives
  • Knowland
  • Dirksen
  • Hendrickson
  • Secretary of the Interior McKay
  • Sparkman
  • Douglas
  • Mansfield
  • Monroney
  • Johnson
  • John F. Kennedy
  • Jackson
  • Gore
1952 May 4-8
Scope and Content Note: Democratic politicians do not like Kefauver, according to this report. There are statements by the following:
  • Douglas - Comments reveal that the nomination might be forced on him
  • Harriman
  • Barkley
  • Russell
Reel   1
1952 February 17-19
Scope and Content Note: The report includes statements by the following:
  • Frank Pace - Truman will not run
  • Anderson - Truman should not run; Eisenhower should come home; Taft is desperate
  • Hennings
  • Benton - Has advised Truman not to run
  • Kerr
  • Kilgore
  • Bridges
  • Nixon - no fear of the Communists as an internal menace, but as part of the world picture
  • Hendrickson
  • Ives
Reel   1
1952 January 14-16
Scope and Content Note: Things which come out in the report are: no Democrat thinks that Truman will run again; no one knows which Republican will run; no one has the stomach for a fight with McCarthy (among the Wisconsin congressmen).
Reel   1
, 1951 September 30-October 3 (Governors' Conference)
Scope and Content Note: The report contains statements by the following:
  • Earl Warren
  • Driscoll
  • Dewey
  • Kohler
  • Peterson
  • Brunsdale
  • Lee
  • Lodge
  • Stevenson - Much to do in Illinois
  • Wright
  • Talmadge
  • Shivers
  • Wetherly
  • Fuller Warren
  • Williams
Reel   1
1951 September 26-28

Scope and Content Note
  • Taft - Am not responsible for McCarthy; no support for Eisenhower
  • Douglas - Eisenhower should run
  • Fulbright - Eisenhower should run; RFC clean now and should not be scrapped
  • Hennings - Truman's “friends”
  • Kefauver
  • Morse
  • Monroney
  • Duff
Reel   1
1951 May 11-16
Scope and Content Note: Opinions coming from this report include: cease fire is imminent; if the Republicans could hold the election now, they could win with a wooden Indian. The report includes statements by the following:
  • Pace - Comments on MacArthur and “victory” ramifications
  • McGhee - Comments on Mideast oil
  • Parrett - Comments on overseas information
  • Taft
  • McMahon
  • Douglas
  • Winthrop Brown - Comments on world trade
Reel   1
1950 December 11-13
Scope and Content Note: The report includes comments by the following:
  • Douglas - No appeasement
  • Taft
  • Lehman
  • McCarran - Comments on people of subversive intent
  • Ives
  • Knowland
  • McCarthy - Admits he wants to destroy the administration and Acheson in particular
  • Wherry
  • Pace
  • Surgeon General Perlman
  • State Department - Comments on the need for balance between Israel and the Arabs
Reel   1
1960 January 18-22
Scope and Content Note: John F. Kennedy and Johnson still do not have enough votes; Stevenson is waning; Hubert Humphrey would run as vice-president with anybody; Symington strong because he is everybody's second choice. The report contains statements by the following:
  • Johnson - Hubert Humphrey is a joke
  • John F. Kennedy - Am putting everything into Wisconsin
  • Hubert Humphrey - Gives Johnson no chance
  • Symington
  • Clinton B. Anderson
  • Dirksen
  • Joseph S. Clark
  • Thruston Morton - Comments on farm problems and Benson
  • Paul Sutler - Democrats cannot win with Johnson
  • Frank Church
  • Henry Jackson
  • Douglas
  • Gore
  • Rayburn
  • S. Wainwright - Republicans are all reactionaries
  • George McGovern
  • A. G. Rogers - Rockefeller should run as vice-president
  • Dr. Keith Glennon (NASA)