Max Otto Papers, 1899-1963


Summary Information
Title: Max Otto Papers
Inclusive Dates: 1899-1963

Creator:
  • Otto, Max Carl, 1876-1968
Call Number: Mss 101

Quantity: 5.6 c.f. (14 archives boxes)

Repository:
Archival Locations:
Wisconsin Historical Society (Map)

Abstract:
Papers of Max Otto, a prominent German American philosopher, teacher at the University of Wisconsin, and controversial figure because of his atheism, pacifism, and defense of academic freedom. Included is correspondence, articles, notes, speeches, lectures, book manuscripts, drawings and cartoons, diaries, an autobiography, newsclippings on criticism of Otto by John B. Chapple in 1932, and other items. The extensive correspondence (1900-1964) provides insight into Otto's long-term intellectual relationship with Boyd S. Bode, John Dewey, and Dickinson S. Miller and into the development of American philosophy during the first half of the twentieth century. Other correspondents include Morton Enslin, Horace Fries, A. Eustace Haydon, Elijah A. Jordan, Horace M. Kallen, Edward C. Lindeman, Alain Locke, Donald Piatt, Harold Taylor, Marten Ten Hoor, Lewis G. Westgate, George C. Sellery, Albert C. Barnes, E. A. Birge, Baker Brownell, Clarence Darrow, Glenn Frank, Nathan Feinsinger, William Leiserson, Alexander Meiklejohn, and Frederick Merk.

Language: English

URL to cite for this finding aid: http://digital.library.wisc.edu/1711.dl/wiarchives.uw-whs-mss00101
 ↑ Bookmark this ↑

Biography/History

Max Carl Otto was born in Zwickau, Germany in 1876. When he was five years old, his parents brought him to Wheeling, West Virginia, where he attended school through the sixth grade. At the age of sixteen, he ran off to Cinncinnati and later to Chicago, where he worked for the R.G. Dun Company. After several years of doing boys work at the Milwaukee Y.M.C.A., he felt the need for more education in order to better understand the true meaning of Christianity. He attended Carroll College in Waukesha, Wisconsin, from 1900 to 1903. In 1903 he came to the University of Wisconsin, where he majored in history under Frederick Jackson Turner and received his B.A. in 1906. He did graduate work in philosophy, and was appointed an assistant in that department in 1908, and an instructor in 1910. By the time he received his Ph.D. in 1911, contact with the thought of William James and John Dewey had made him a humanistic atheist. He became a full professor of philosophy in 1921. In 1922 he married Rhoda Owen of Milwaukee; they had a son, Owen, and a daughter, Mary.

Until his retirement in 1947, Max Otto was one of the most popular professors at the University of Wisconsin. His great originality and wide appeal stemmed from the fact that he regarded philosophy as inextricably linked with the search for a better life, concrete assistance to individuals, and social concerns. As a pragmatist and an instrumentalist, he repudiated metaphysical ideals and attempted to instill his students with a critical yet tolerant spirit and the ability to find constructive solutions for real problems. The famous philosophy course he taught from 1910 to 1936, “Man and Nature,” in which he examined the impact of theories of evolution on man's concept of himself, aroused great controversy. Max Otto became the target for the attacks of those outraged by his atheism, pacifism, and defense of academic freedom, notably many religious leaders in 1915 and 1916 and the politician John B. Chapple in 1932.

Max Otto expounded his ideas of philosophy's relevance and human possibilities in three books: Things and Ideals (1924), Natural Laws and Human Hopes (1926), and The Human Enterprise (1940). In addition to a large output of articles, he collaborated in Is There a God?, a debate first published in The Christian Century, a volume for William James' centennial in 1942, and Philosophy in American Education (1945), a report by a commission appointed by the American Philosophical Association.

His achievements were honored at a Jubilee Dinner on the occasion of his retirement in 1947. He died in Madison in 1968.

References:

  • Burkhardt, Frederick, ed. The Cleavage in Our Culture: Studies in Scientific Humanism in Honor of Max Otto, Boston, Massachusetts: Beacon Press, 1952.
  • Wilder, Amos Tappan, “The Joint-Venturer,” an unpublished M.A. thesis at the University of Wisconsin, 1967.
Scope and Content Note

The Max Otto Papers consist of correspondence, articles, research notes, speeches, lecture notes and other writings, diaries, his autobiography, clippings, and memorabilia. They are arranged in four series: correspondence, writings, biographical materials, and reference materials.

The CORRESPONDENCE is arranged chronologically from 1899 to 1963. There are very few outgoing letters before 1929. In addition to insights on Otto's life and thought, this correspondence reflects the development of American philosophy over a forty-year period. Most valuable to the researcher is the Boyd H. Bode correspondence, which spans the period from 1908 to 1950. In these letters Bode encouraged Otto in his effort to make philosophy relevant to life.. The correspondence with John Dewey reflects the deep friendship between the two men and provides many commentaries on their colleagues in philosophy. The voluminous correspondence with Dickinson S. Miller (which is found throughout from 1927 on) a companion of William James, is also valuable from the philosophical standpoint. In addition, the letters exchanged with prominent figures of the University of Wisconsin and American philosophers such as Albert C. Barnes, Dean E. A. Birge, Baker Brownell, Morton Enslin, University President Glenn Frank, Nathan P. Feininger, Horace Fries, A. Eustace Haydon, Elijah A. Jordon, Horace M. Kallen, William M. Leiserson, Edward C. Linderman, Alain Locke, Alexander Meiklejohn, Frederick Merk, Donald Piatt, Dean George C. Sellery, Harold Taylor, Marten Ten Hoor, and Lewis G. Westgate, give a good picture of the development of American pragmatism, and of the conflicts among American philosophers and within the University of Wisconsin during this period. There is also extensive correspondence between Otto and the editorial staff of The Christian Century, The Crozer Quarterly, The Humanist, The Humanist Press Association, The Journal of Social Philosophy, and The Nation.

A list of the dates of correspondence with Boyd H. Bode, Clarence Darrow, John Dewey, Alexander Meiklejohn, and George C. Sellery is an appendix to this finding aid.

All of the correspondence between Otto and his close friend Phillip La Follette may be found in the additions to the Phillip LaFollette Papers (Wis Mss QS). There is, however, some correspondence between Otto and Phillip's son Robert in this collection, during the years following 1944.

The WRITINGS AND PROFESSIONAL PAPERS series is comprised of the records and papers generated by Max Otto's professional activities, including: (1) his writings -- published and unpublished articles; notes of articles, books, and speeches; and reviews; (2) his lecture notes for University of Wisconsin courses; and (3) his speeches. These materials are arranged chronologically within each category. The articles are preceded by a Bibliography Progress Report dated 1956. The folder of newspaper articles provides an index of Otto's many interests, such as education and theology, and his pacifist and progressive political sentiments. The next two folders contain drafts of About Thinking, the book on logic which Otto worked on for thirty years but did not complete. The folders of miscellaneous notes include fragments of his book The Human Enterprise. The undated book reviews written by Otto are arranged alphabetically by the name of the book's author. The lecture notes for his University of Wisconsin courses are not complete; there is material only from the late 1930s and 1951 and there are no notes for the well-known “Man and Nature” course. The speeches given outside the University include Otto's addresses to the First Unitarian Society of Madison and other Unitarian groups.

The third series, BIOGRAPHICAL MATERIALS, includes all of Max Otto's public expression with the exception of his drawings and the muck-raking political cartoons which he drew for the Wisconsin State Journal between the years 1907 and 1910. These have been placed with the biographical materials because they were done before Otto chose a career in philosophy and because they relate to politics and events of those years. Thus, they were considered to be more of a biographical nature rather than as material revealing Otto's professional thoughts and ideas. Max Otto's autobiography, his diaries, biographical clippings arranged chronologically, and memorabilia make up the remainder of this third series. The drafts of five chapters of the autobiography, “He Came to Himself,” are written as a novel, in the third person. In this fictionalized account, Otto, in the words of Amos Tappan Wilder, tries to “read himself into the optimistic American experience, the American dream.” There is also a piece written during World War I at the height of anti-German feeling, “Living Down the Hyphen.” The first notebook of his diary gives a detailed account of his attempt to prevent the firing of Professor Fiese in 1917 because of an “unpatriotic” remark, but unfortunately the diary resumes only in 1955, passing over the period when he was most severely criticized in the 1930s. The biographical clippings from Wisconsin newspapers bridge this gap.

The fourth series of the collection contains REFERENCE AND RESOURCE MATERIALS: colleagues' and students' papers, a Japanese account of American philosophy and Otto's thought, materials concerning The Humanist, and articles annotated by Max Otto. There are files of reference clippings on incidents threatening academic freedom; on John B. Chapple, the politician who attacked Otto in 1932; on Otto's fellow philosophers; and on other matters which interested him. They are arranged in chronological order.

A list of the books, periodicals, reprints, and pamphlets which were sent to the Historical Society Library, in alphabetical order on index cards, is in the last box of the collection.

Administrative/Restriction Information
Acquisition Information

Primarily presented by Mrs. Rhoda Owen Otto, October 6, 1964. Xerox copies of three letters from Otto to Walter L. Rankin of Carroll College (September 27, 1904, April 16, 1905, July 16, 1908) and one letter from Otto to Alfred S. Badger, a Carroll College trustee (September 30, 1905) were received from the Carroll College Library in 1974 and were interfiled in the correspondence. An annotated draft of Otto's autobiography was loaned for Xeroxing by Peter Odegard, Hudson, Wisconsin, in 1974 and the copy was added to Box 12. Accession Number: M74-359, M74-382, M74-544


Contents List
Series: Correspondence
Box   1
Folder   1
1899 March 5-1900
Box   1
Folder   2
1901-1904
Box   1
Folder   3
1905-1907
Box   1
Folder   4
1908-1909
Box   1
Folder   5
1910-1911
Box   1
Folder   6
1912-1913
Box   1
Folder   7
1914-1916
Box   1
Folder   8
1917-1918
Box   1
Folder   9
1919-1920
Box   1
Folder   10
1921-1923
Box   1
Folder   11
1924-1925
Box   1
Folder   12
1926-1927
Box   1
Folder   13
1928
Box   2
Folder   1
1929
Box   2
Folder   2
1930 January 1-June 30
Box   2
Folder   3
1930 July 1-December 31
Box   2
Folder   4
1931 January 1-March 31
Box   2
Folder   5
1931 April 1-July 31
Box   2
Folder   6
1931 August 1-October 31
Box   2
Folder   7
1931 November 1-December 31
Box   2
Folder   8
1932 January 1-February 29
Box   2
Folder   9
1932 March 1-May 31
Box   2
Folder   10
1932 June 1-September 30
Box   2
Folder   11
1932 October 1-November 30
Box   2
Folder   12
1932 December 1-1933 March 1
Box   2
Folder   13
1933 April 1-June 30
Box   3
Folder   1
1933 July 1-October 1
Box   3
Folder   2
1933 November 1-1934 January 31
Box   3
Folder   3
1934 February 1-April 30
Box   3
Folder   4
1934 May 1-August 31
Box   3
Folder   5
1934 September 1-December 31
Box   3
Folder   6
1935 January 1-May 31
Box   3
Folder   7
1935 June 1-December 31 and undated
Box   3
Folder   8
1936 January 1-June 30
Box   3
Folder   9
1936 July 1-December 31 and undated
Box   3
Folder   10
1937 January 1-April 30
Box   3
Folder   11
1937 May 1-September 30
Box   4
Folder   1
1937 October 1-December 31 and undated
Box   4
Folder   2
1938 January 1-June 30
Box   4
Folder   3
1938 July 1-December 31 and undated
Box   4
Folder   4
1939 January 1-June 30
Box   4
Folder   5
1939 July 1-December 31 and undated
Box   4
Folder   6
1940 January 1-February 29
Box   4
Folder   7
1940 March 1-April 30
Box   4
Folder   8
1940 May 1-June 30
Box   4
Folder   9
1940 July 1-August 31
Box   4
Folder   10
1940 September 1-October 30
Box   4
Folder   11
1940 November 1-December 31 and undated
Box   5
Folder   1
1941 January 1-February 28
Box   5
Folder   2
1941 March 1-April 30
Box   5
Folder   3
1941 May 1-June 30
Box   5
Folder   4
1941 July 1-August 31
Box   5
Folder   5
1941 September 1-October 31
Box   5
Folder   6
1941 November 1-December 31 and undated
Box   5
Folder   7
1942 January 1-April 30
Box   5
Folder   8
1942 May 1-August 31
Box   5
Folder   9
1942 September 1-October 31
Box   5
Folder   10
1942 November 1-December 31 and undated
Box   5
Folder   11
1943 January 1-April 30
Box   6
Folder   1
1943 May 1-August 31
Box   6
Folder   2
1943 September 1-October 31
Box   6
Folder   3
1943 November 1-December 31 and undated
Box   6
Folder   4
1944 January 1-February 29
Box   6
Folder   5
1944 March 1-April 30
Box   6
Folder   6
1944 May 1-July 31
Box   6
Folder   7
1944 August 1-October 31
Box   6
Folder   8
1944 November 1-December 31 and undated
Box   6
Folder   9
1945 January 1-February 28
Box   6
Folder   10
1945 March 1-April 30
Box   6
Folder   11
1945 May 1-July 30
Box   7
Folder   1
1945 July 1-August 30
Box   7
Folder   2
1945 September 1-October 31
Box   7
Folder   3
1945 November 1-December 31 and undated
Box   7
Folder   4
1946 January 1-February 28
Box   7
Folder   5
1946 March 1-April 30
Box   7
Folder   6
1946 May 1-June 30
Box   7
Folder   7
1946 July 1-October 30
Box   7
Folder   8
1946 November 1-December 31 and undated
Box   7
Folder   9
1947 January 1-February 28
Box   7
Folder   10
1947 March 1-April 30
Box   7
Folder   11
1947 May 1-June 30
Box   7
Folder   12
1947 July 1-October 31
Box   7
Folder   13
1947 November 1-December 31 and undated
Box   8
Folder   1
1948 January 1-June 30
Box   8
Folder   2
1948 July 1-December 31 and undated
Box   8
Folder   3
1949 January 1-June 30
Box   8
Folder   4
1949 July 1-December 31 and undated
Box   8
Folder   5
1950
Box   8
Folder   6
1951
Box   8
Folder   7
1952
Box   8
Folder   8
1953 January 1-June 30
Box   8
Folder   9
1953 July 1-December 31 and undated
Box   8
Folder   10
1954
Box   8
Folder   11
1955
Box   8
Folder   12
1956
Box   8
Folder   13
1957
Box   9
Folder   1
1958
Box   9
Folder   2
1959-1961
Box   9
Folder   3
1962-1964 February 10
Box   9
Folder   4
Undated
Series: Writings and Professional Papers
Box   9
Folder   5
Progress Report on Bibliography, 1956
Articles, published and unpublished
Box   9
Folder   6
1910-1925
Box   9
Folder   7
1926-1931
Box   9
Folder   8
1932-1940
Box   9
Folder   9
1941-1943
Box   9
Folder   10
1944-1951
Box   10
Folder   1
1952-1959, and undated
Box   10
Folder   1
Newspaper Articles, 1913-1953
Notes for About Thinking and Drafts
Box   10
Folder   2
Chapter I
Box   10
Folder   3
Chapters II and III
Box   10
Folder   4-6
Miscellaneous Notes for Articles, Speeches, and Books
Reviews of Max Otto's Books
Box   10
Folder   7
The Human Enterprise
Box   10
Folder   8
Natural Laws and Human Hopes
Box   10
Folder   9
Things and Ideals
Reviews by Max Otto
Box   10
Folder   10
1917-1941
Box   10
Folder   11
1942-1954
Box   10
Folder   12
Undated, arranged alphabetically by the book's author
Lecture Materials, University of Wisconsin
Box   11
Folder   1
A-C
Box   11
Folder   2
D-F
Box   11
Folder   3
G-K
Box   11
Folder   4
L-Q
Box   11
Folder   5
R-S
Box   11
Folder   6
T-Z
Speeches and Speech Materials of Max Otto, outside the University of Wisconsin
Box   12
Folder   1
1900-1947
Box   12
Folder   2
1950-1953
Series: Biographical Materials
Autobiography
Box   12
Folder   3
“He Came to Himself” and “Living Down the Hyphen”
Box   12
Folder   4
Drafts Written for Lewis C. Westgate, 1945
Box   12
Folder   5
Notes and Resource Materials
Clippings about Max Otto
Box   12
Folder   6
1911-1933
Box   12
Folder   7
1934-1968
Box   12
Folder   8
Undated
Box   12
Folder   9
Drawings, Sketches, and Wisconsin State Journal political cartoons
Diary
Box   12
Folder   10
1917 November 22-December 14; 1955 January, June-September; 1956 January-December
Box   13
Folder   1
1957 January-May, September-October; 1958 January-March, May-August, October-November; 1963 July-November
Box   13
Folder   2-3
Max Otto Jubilee Dinner, Correspondence and Memorabilia, 1947
Series: Reference Materials
Box   13
Folder   4
Resource Materials
Scope and Content Note: A Japanese account of American pragmatism and Otto's thought, materials concerning The Humanist, colleagues' papers, students' papers, and miscellaneous resource materials.
Others' Articles Annotated by Otto
Box   13
Folder   5
Blanshard to Kallen
Box   13
Folder   6
Leander to Putnam
Box   13
Folder   7
Russell to Willkie
Reference Clippings
Box   14
Folder   1
Academic Freedom
Box   14
Folder   2
John B. Chapple
Box   14
Folder   3
Colleagues and Correspondents of Max Otto
Box   14
Folder   4
Miscellaneous
Appendix: Correspondence of Particular Interest
Correspondent Dates Comments
Boyd H. Bode (Incoming and Outgoing) 1908: July 3, August 9 For a discussion of Bode's life and work, see the correspondence between Max Otto and H. Gordon Hullfish, 1955-1957.
1909: July 14, August 31, September 10, 21, 25, October 8, 10 November 8, December 12, 23
1910: January 8, 13, 26, undated, March 7, 14, 27, April 19, 24, 29, May 4, 6, 10, 12, 14, 24, June 8, July 15, undated
1911: February 2, March 1, April 13, May 1, 22, 28, September 10, October 22, December 7
1912: March 7, April 22, May 4, June 3, 10, July 22, 31, September 25, November 1, 26
1913: January 16, 21, February 9, 16, April 25, June 4, 25, July 11, 26, September 19, October 9, 13, 28, November 5, December 17, 30
1914: January 16, 17, 28, February 16, 20, March 6, 10, 13, 17, 25, 29, April 2, 3, 4, May 12, June 12, 23, July 10, August 24, October 21, November 10, December 22, undated
1915: July 13, December 7
1916: January 8, September 22, December 24
1917: February 1, March 18, 21, May 25, June 14, July 2, October 19, November 6
1918: March 18, 20, April 10, August 1, November 8, 30, December 12
1919: January 3, 29, February 1, 13, 22, March 4, 12, April 6, 9, May 18, July 22, August 5, 12, September 8, 10, October 4, 10, 18, 27, 31, November 20, December 9
1920: February 18, 19, March 22, April 11, 29, August 22, September 19, November 2
1921: February 7, March 22, April 2, 11, 20, 21, May 2, 16, June 1, 26, July 19, 22, August 31, October 7, 9, 14
1922: January 8, 11, February 14, March 3, 22, April 20, September 23, 30, October 24, November 24, December 21, 24, 26
1923: November 11, 16, 29
1924: January 5, 15, March 15, 28, June 9, August 9, 16, 30, September 27, October 23, November 2, undated
1925: May 17, June 7, September 24, October 18
1926: January 2, March 26, June 16, August 25, September 11 1927: January 2, November 15, December 21
1928: March 19, 28, July 18, October 9, 13, November 27
1929: February 17, 22, March 10, 18, April 12, 25, May 3, 10, 22, July 19, September 17, November 19, December 9, 18
1930: January 5, 14, 19, 30, February 17, 26, May 5, June 18, July 19, 25, October 11, 29, November 7, 20, December 5
1931: February 20, May 13, June 3, 11, 12, 16, 25, 27, September 11, November 12, 16, 19, 20, December 6, 10, 12, 14, 15, 19
1932: January 13, 20, February 11, 13, March 22, 23, 24, 26, April 25, September 22, October 6, November 22, December 21
1933: January 10, May 1, 5, June 16, August 16, December 31
1934: February 8, March 6, April 10, June 6, August 17, October 1, 6, 31, November 3
1935: February 12, April 17, May 2, July 5, 10, 16, November 12 1936: February 7, April 6
1937: January 5, 6, 14, March 11, 31, April 2, 5, 17, August 8, September 13
1938: January 21, May 25, undated, December 21
1939: November 29
1940: January 16, May 9, June 29, July 12, August 23, September 20, December 3, 11, 18
1941: January 9, 31, March 3, 15, April 9, 11, 23, May 26, June 13, August 17, October 29, November 13
1942: January 17, 26, February 24, March 9, 10, 27, April 19, 25, June 17, September 25, October 6, 28, November 5, 30, December 9
1943: January 7, March 4, April 26, June 24, July 23, August 18, 23, September 17, 26, October 14, 17, November 3, 11, December 12
1944: January 2, 12, 18, February 25, May 9, undated
1945: March 1, July 28, August 3, September 12, October 25, November 19
1946: February 4, 5, April 3, 14, September 16, October 6, November 13, 22
1947: Apri1 28, 30, May 17, 30, October 28, November 12, 29, December 5, 12
1948: February 18, March 28, May 1, July 21, October 14, 21
1949: January 23, May 2, August 23, October 31, December 21
1950: March 13, May 22, August 27, September 17
1951: January 7, 28, April 6, May 22, July 3, 7, 31, November 17, December 18
1952: February 24, June 4, August 25, October 14, 18, November 20, December 18, 25, 31
Clarence Darrow (Both incoming and outgoing) 1926: November 21 See also the correspondence between Ruby (Mrs. Clarence) Darrow for several years during Clarence Darrow's illness and following his death (circa 1937-1941).
1932: October 6, 29
1933: September 12
1935: February 6, 8
1936: November 30
John Dewey (Incoming and Outgoing) 1917: May 10 See also the correspondence between Robby (Mrs. John) Dewey and Jane Dewey and Max and Rhoda Otto: 1951, August 3, October 25; 1952, March 4, June 11, July 11; and 1953, December 1
1923: February 26, March 9, October 31, November 21
1924: October 18
1925: November 25
1926: January 2, April 6, May 27, November 22
1928: October 22, 30, November 27, December 19
1929: January 8, 25, October 7, 17, November 7, December 18
1930: October 1, 11, 15, November 1, 11, December 1, 4
1931: October 10
1933: March 5, April 11, 28
1934: January 4, February 19, 28
1935: January 25, May 3, August 16, 22
1936: December 18
1939: September 3, 29, October 23, November 28, December 19
1940: January 4, April l8, 22, 30, May 3, 5, 15, 21, June 4, July 6, 10, 18, 29, 31, August 2, 16, 28, September 7
1941: January 23, February 4, 11, 22, 26, March 4, April 29, May 13, June 5, July 2, 7, 14, October 7, November 10, 19, December 2, 4, undated
1942: May 8, 21, June 22, October 8, November 8, 16, December 3, 22, 28
1943: October 27, December 10
1944: January 12, 14, May 29, July 21, October 11, 19, November 6
1945: January 30, February 11, March 6, October 11, November 11, December 28
1946: January 14, December 6, 9 (2)
1947: March 5, April 14, July 14, 19
1948: October 30, November 6
1949: January 26, August 12, 27, September 4, November 5, 8, 27
1950: May 10, 17, June 17, 29, July 23, October 6, 9, 27
1951: January 2, 28, February 14, 23, August 15, November 16
Alexander Meiklejohn (Incoming and Outgoing) 1931: May 5
1932: February 7, April 1, 2, undated
1933: November 10, 22
1934: January 4, 14, February 15, March 9
1935: November 25
1936: January 12, April 21
1938: March 29, April 6, May 14
1941: January 17
1949: April 2
1959: December 14
1961: January 5
1962: January 5, March 12, April 2
George C. Sellery (Incoming and Outgoing) 1929: October 1 Also see Box 13, Folder 2, which contains George Sellery's correspondence with various University of Wisconsin professors about the Max Otto Jubilee Dinner on October 26, 1947.
1930: April 22, 24, September 18
1931: April 7
1932: July 8
1935: January 3, December 30
1937: December 13
1939: August 22, October 8, November 2, 9, 10, December 4
1940: August 27
1941: July 29
1942: January 21
1947: July 10, 17, August 1, 15, 18, 27, September 9, 16, 27, 29, October 16, 27, 30, November 2, 18, 26, December 17
1948: January 3, 16, 24, February 2, 13
1956: April 17