Page 2199

CONVENTION DEBATES AND PROCEEDINGS, 17 JULY 1788
MELANCTON SMITH. was not presentl4-& heard the whole of what
has been said-the questn. at present is for an adjournt. still wishes
something may be brought forward to conciliate- [Gilbert Livingston,
Notes, NN]
JOHN SLOSS HOBART. Made this Motion-purely to put off the
questn. before the house-but wishes some thing may be proposed-
to conciliate [Gilbert Livingston, Notes, NN]
CONVENTION PROCEEDINGS. Question put-
for an adjournment-22-
against it- 40- [Gilbert Livingston, Notes, NN]
CONVENTION PROCEEDINGS. After debates being had, Mr. President
put the question thereon, and it was carried in the negative, in the
manner following, viz.
For the Negative. [40]
Mr. R. Yates,
Mr. Lansing,
Mr. Oothoudt,
Mr. Vrooman,
Mr. I. Thompson,
Mr. Ten Eyck,
Mr. Swart,
Mr. Scudder,
Mr. J. Smith,
Mr. Tredwell,
Mr. Jay,
Mr. R. Morris,
Mr. Hobart,
Mr. Hamilton,
Mr. R. Livingston,
Mr. Roosevelt,
Mr. Cantine,
Mr. Schoonmaker,
Mr. Clark,
Mr. J. Clinton,
Mr. Wynkoop,
Mr. Lawrence,
Mr. Carman,
Mr. Haring,
Mr. Woodhull,
Mr. Wisner,
Mr. Wood,
Mr. Platt,
Mr. M. Smith,
Mr. Swartwout,
Mr. Akins,
Mr. G. Livingston,
Mr. D'Witt,
Mr. Harper,
Mr. C. Yates,
Mr. Frey,
Mr. Winn,
Mr. Veeder,
Mr. Staring,
Mr. Parker,
Mr. Williams,
Mr. Baker,
Mr. Hopkins,
Mr. Van Ness,
Mr. Bay,
Mr. Adgate,
For the Affirmative. [22]
Mr. Duane,
Mr. Harison,
Mr. Low,
Mr. Havens,
Mr. Jones,
Mr. Schenck,         Mr. P. Livingston,
Mr. Lefferts,        Mr. Hatfield,
Mr. Vandervoort,     Mr. Van Cortlandt,
Mr. Bancker,         Mr. Crane,
Mr. Ryerss,          Mr. Sarls,
Mr. L. Morris,
[Convention Journal, 38-39] 15
CONVENTION PROCEEDINGS. Motn. to go into the committee of the
whole
In Committee-
Jay's Motn read'6
Smiths Motn. read7- [Gilbert Livingston, Notes, NN]
2199