Hazard, H. W. (ed.) / The fourteenth and fifteenth centuries
II: Byzantium and the Crusades, 1261-1354, pp. [unnumbered]-68 PDF (16.6 MB)
30 A HISTORY OF THE CRUSADES III that in these tenth-century Byzantine expeditions to Syria and Pales tine, the Greek soldiers did not wear the cross as a badge, nor did they term their wars "crusades."4 Rather, behind their expeditions was not so much the concept of freeing the Holy Land from "the pollution of the infidel" as the desire to restore to the authority of the basileus certain lost areas of the Basileia, the sacred empire, in particular Syria and Palestine. The Byzantine lack of appreciation for the religious aspect of western crusading ideology may already be seen during the First Crusade. Even the usually astute Anna Comnena demonstrated a certain lack of insight when she viewed all the western knights merely as predatory, bent only on looting the empire. Nor does the sophisticated emperor Alexius I seem truly to have appreciated the extent of the genuine piety in crusader motivations. He was, to be sure, amazed at the masses of westerners who left home and family to take the cross. But he always suspected that the motive of self-aggrandizement, the personal ambition of the leaders, was at the bottom of all crusading ventures, despite the outpouring of pious fervor that manifested itself on the surface. Alexius's worst fears of Latin motivations were confirmed by the aggressive actions of Bohe mond—fears transmitted to his grandson, Manuel I, and from him to all subsequent Greek emperors. By Manuel's time (1143—1180) there was greater reason for the Byzantine suspicion of the crusading movement. For during the Second Crusade (1147) Louis VII of France had contemplated taking Constantinople, and similarly in 1185 the late Manuel's archenemy, the German emperor Frederick I Barbarossa, encamped before the walls of the capital, had pondered whether to assault the city. After the Fourth Crusade in 1204, with its unparalleled looting of Constantinople and enforced Greek con version to "Catholicism," Byzantine suspicions and fears of the Latins had became so ineradicably a part of their psychology that nothing thereafter seemed able to assuage them. Accordingly, from the time of the Greek recovery of Constantino ple by Michael VIII in 1261 until the final fall of the city in 1453, croisade: Les premiers croisades (Paris, 1959), is of little help on the Byzantine side. See also S. Runciman, "The Byzantine Provincial Peoples and the Crusade," Relazioni del X Congresso Internazionale di Scienze Storiche, III (1955), 621—624. 4. Possibly the first, or one of the first, Byzantine uses of the western term crusade is in Nicetas Choniates (staurophoroi: bearers of the cross), referring to the western knights of the First Crusade coming to Constantinople. This term is not used during the 9th- and 10th-century Byzantine campaigns in Syria and Palestine, and the Greek church, though it blessed the Greek armies and was anxious for the recovery of the holy places and holy relics, did not promise any special rewards such as remission of sins to the expedition's partici pants.
Copyright 1975 The Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System. All rights reserved. Use of this material falling outside the purview of "fair use" requires the permission of the University of Wisconsin Press. To buy the hardcover book, see: http://www/wisc/edu/wisconsinpress/books/1734.htm