Page View
Wolff, R. L.; Hazard, H. W. (ed.) / Volume II: The later Crusades, 1189-1311
(1969)
XI: The Fifth Crusade, pp. 376-428
PDF (13.1 MB)
Page 380
380 A HISTORY OF THE CRUSADES II to the royal family and to the clergy of France to give him whole hearted support.4 Soon after Robert's arrival in France, he sum moned a council to deal especially with the difficult question of usury, through which many of the nobles and clergy had been pauperized and, as a consequence, could not afford to give the desired support to the crusade. But the clergy of France complained bitterly to the pope of the legate's encroachments upon their authority, of his avarice, and of the slanderous abuse to which they were subjected, both by the legate and by the crusading preachers associated with him. Contemporary sources are in agreement that his imprudent conduct had incurred general hatred. Philip Augustus supported the clergy in their complaints, and the pope, seeing the grave danger to the success of the crusade, acknowledged the excessive zeal of Robert, although pleading extenuating circum stances.5 The preaching of Robert of Courçon, like that of his greater contemporary James of Vitry, was most successful among the masses, the unfortunate, and the weak. He permitted all who volunteered to accept the cross: old men, women, children, crip ples, the deaf, and the blind. William the Breton, a contemporary historian, alleges that many nobles refused to take the cross because of the difficulties and confusion occasioned by the presence of so many ill-suited to the task of a crusade.6 But this was largely Innocent's fault: in his anxiety lest aid to the Holy Land be unduly delayed, the pope had expressly admonished his agents not to take the time, at the moment when the cross was assumed, to examine too closely the physical or moral fitness of the crusaders. Exceptions could be made later in all cases of urgent necessity. In the autumn of 121 5, when Robert returned to Rome to participate in the Fourth Lateran Council, the prelates of France, in his presence, placed before the pope their list of grievances, so numerous and, in many instances, so well founded that the pope could only plead with the prelates to forgive the legate's indiscre tions.7 Yet, at the end of 1 218, at the request — incredible as it may seem — of the French crusaders, Robert was sent to Palestine by Honorius III as spiritual adviser to the French fleet, but in all things subordinate to the recently chosen papal legate, cardinal Pelagius.8 PL, CCXVI, cols. 827—828; RHGF, XIX, 579. Du Theil, "Mémoire," pp. 578—580. See also the letter of Innocent III (May 14, 1214) to Philip Augustus in RHGF, XIX, 59. 6 De gestis Philippi Augusti, in RHGF, XVII, 108. Ex chronologia Roberti Altissiodorensis, in RHGF, XVIII, 283. 8 P. Pressutti (ed.), Regesta Honoriipapae III (2 vols., Berlin, 1874—1875), nos. 1498, 1558; O. Rinaldi ("Raynaldus"), Annales ecciesiastici, ad ann. 1218, no. 5 (vol. XIII, Rome, 1646).
Copyright 1969 The Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System. All rights reserved. Use of this material falling outside the purview of "fair use" requires the permission of the University of Wisconsin Press. To buy the paperback book, see: http://www.wisc.edu/wisconsinpress/books/1733.htm